Making Good Use of Existing Space: Add an Addition or Remodel?

As homeowners, we often find ourselves at a crossroads: Do we need more space, or should we improve how we use the space we already have? The decision to add an addition to your home or remodel an existing space is significant and requires careful consideration. Both options come with their own set of benefits, challenges, and costs. 

Choosing the right path depends on several factors, including your budget, your current home’s functionality, future plans, and personal preferences.

When deciding whether to build an addition or remodel your current home or space, it’s essential to consider several key factors. Evaluating the pros and cons of each option can help you determine the best choice for your family’s needs and lifestyle.

First, Assess the Situation

Before diving into the details of adding or remodeling, the first step is assessing your space needs. Ask yourself these critical questions:

Do you need more space? 

If your family has outgrown your home and you need a few more bedrooms, a larger kitchen, or additional living space, it may be time to add an extension. But, if you just want a little more space or functionality, a remodel might do the trick.

What is your space used for? 

Most houses still have basements, attics, or sitting rooms that no one ever uses. Remodeling these rooms will allow you to fix them without having to make your home bigger.

What are you looking for over the long term? 

If you plan to live in your home long-term, paying for an addition or remodel that best suits your long-term objectives may be worth your while. Conversely, if you’re selling soon, think about your decision’s impact on your home’s resale value.

By looking at your current space and its use, you’ll have an accurate picture of what might work better: an addition or a complete renovation.

The Pros and Cons of Remodeling

Remodeling focuses on optimizing your existing space without expanding your home’s footprint. This option is often more cost-effective than building an addition, and it allows for creative solutions that can enhance your home’s functionality and aesthetic appeal.

The Pros:

Maximizes Current Space: Remodeling enables you to make the most of the space you already possess. Renovating a basement, for instance, into a family room, an attic into a home office, or a cramped kitchen is an effective way to give used and unused spaces new life.

More Affordable Than an Addition: As a rule of thumb, remodeling is cheaper than an addition. You save time and money if you don’t have to build a new foundation, roof, and exterior coating.

Construction Time: Remodeling requires fewer structural changes than an addition, so construction is quicker. This is especially vital if you don’t wish to be disturbed by a lengthy construction phase.

More Flow and Functionality: With a proper remodel, your house will flow better and be more functional and open to your lifestyle. For example, breaking down walls between rooms or moving doors and windows can make the whole space feel very different.

The Cons:
Existing Configuration Restrictions: If you’re renovating, you have to work within the boundaries of your current building configuration. This means that even drastic design changes—a larger master suite or a small kitchen—might not be possible.

Hidden Costs and Surprises: Rehab work in older houses might reveal unintended problems such as wiring deterioration, plumbing leakage, or structural issues. Such hidden problems can increase the project’s expense and time.

Less Resale Potential: A remodel can absolutely increase the overall livability and value of your home, but it may not deliver the same ROI as an addition if your total square footage is the same.

The Pros and Cons of an Addition

Adding an addition is often the best solution if you need more space. Whether you’re expanding your living room, adding a new bedroom, or building a home office, an addition allows you to increase your home’s square footage and create custom spaces tailored to your needs.

The Pros:

More Space: The obvious advantage of an addition is the ability to generate additional square footage. Add a second story, an upper floor, or a roof over the garage, and you can take advantage of your expanding family or lifestyle.

Customization: With an addition, you have the freedom to design new spaces from scratch, tailoring them to your specific needs and preferences. This level of customization is often difficult to achieve with a remodel.

Higher Home Value: In general, if you can add a bedroom or bathroom, it will typically raise your house’s value. A larger home can be sold at a premium, and certain upgrades (like a master suite or contemporary kitchen) are popular with the buyers.

Future-Proofing Your Home: If you’re in your home long term, a renovation can also allow you to change the space around for later scenarios, whether that’s aging in place, extended family, or renting a spare room to make extra cash.

The Cons:

Higher Costs: Adding an addition is typically more expensive than remodeling. The costs associated with building new foundations, walls, roofing, and exterior finishes add up quickly. Additionally, you may need to obtain permits, hire architects, and deal with zoning regulations, all of which can drive up the cost.

Disruption to Daily Life: Construction on an addition can be disruptive, especially if you’re building onto frequently used areas of your home like the kitchen or living room. In some cases, you may need to move out temporarily while the work is being done.

Longer Timeline: Building an addition is a more complex process than remodeling, and it typically takes longer to complete. This extended timeline can be a drawback if you’re looking to finish the project quickly.

Zoning and Permit Challenges: Depending on where you live, adding an addition may require navigating local zoning laws and building codes. Setback requirements, height restrictions, and other regulations can limit what you’re able to build and where.

Making the Right Decision For You and Your Family

When deciding between adding an addition or remodeling your home, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on your unique needs, budget, and long-term goals. 

Here are some key factors to consider:

Costs: If you’re on a limited budget, then a remodel can be worth the investment. But if you’re willing to pay more for extra room and customization, an upgrade might be worth it.

Space Restrictions: If you don’t have a large lot or your house has an awkward layout, remodeling may be your solution for more living space. Alternatively, if you already have space to spare, an addition might just give you the extra space you desire.

Resale Value: See how each option will affect the sale price of your house. More square footage through an addition usually provides a better ROI, but a well-done remodel can also make your home more marketable.

Contact Our Office for Immediate Assistance

In the end, whether it is an addition or a remodeling project, you need to plan ahead to ensure that you are getting the most out of your investment both today and in the future. By assessing space needs, cost, and desired future, you can decide what’s right for your home and your lifestyle. Contact Marcela Montoya Remodeling for immediate assistance.

REQUEST A PERSONAL CONSULTATION WITH MARCELA MONTOYA

Name
Address
Address
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

All initial design services are free. All submitted information is strictly confidential.